Charles had been at great pains in bringing
the members to join in this request. Having observed a considerable variety of
sentiments among the protestants with respect to the submission which he had
required to the decrees of the council, some of them being altogether
intractable, while others were ready to acknowledge its right of jurisdiction
upon certain conditions, he employed all his address in order to gain or to
divide them.
He threatened and overawed the elector Palatine, a weak prince,
and afraid that the emperor might inflict on him the punishment to which lie
had made himself liable by the assistance that he had given to the confederates
of Smalkalde. The hope of procuring liberty for the landgrave, together with
the formal confirmation of his own electoral dignity, overcame Maurice’s
scruples, or prevented him from opposing what he knew would be agreeable to the
emperor. The elector of Brandenburg, less influenced by religious zeal than any
prince of that age, was easily induced to imitate their example, in assenting
to all that the emperor required. The deputies of the cities remained still to
be brought over.
They were more tenacious of their principles, and though everything
that could operate either on their hopes or fears was tried, the utmost that
they would promise was, to acknowledge the jurisdiction of the council, if
effectual provision were made for securing to the divines of all parties free
access to that assembly, with entire liberty of debate; and if all points in
controversy were decided according to scripture, and the usage of the primitive
church. But when the memorial containing this declaration was presented to the
emperor, he ventured to put in practice a very extraordinary artifice. Without
reading, the paper, or taking any notice of the conditions on which they had
insisted, he seemed to take it for granted that they had complied with his
demand, and gave thanks to the deputies for their full and unreserved
submission to the decrees of the council [Oct. 9]. The deputies, though astonished at
what they had heard, did not attempt to set him right, both parties being
better pleased that the matter should remain under this state of ambiguity,
than to push for an explanation, which must have occasioned a dispute, and
would have led, perhaps, to a rupture.
Having
obtained this seeming submission from the members of the diet to the authority
of the council, Charles employed that as an argument to enforce their petition
for its return to Trent. But the pope, from the satisfaction which he felt in
mortifying the emperor, as well as from his own aversion to what was demanded,
resolved, without hesitation, that his petition should not be granted; though,
in order to avoid the imputation of being influenced wholly by resentment, he
had the address to throw it upon the fathers at Bologna, to put a direct
negative upon the request.
With this view he referred to their consideration
the petition of the diet [Dec. 20], and they, ready to confirm by their assent
whatever the legates were pleased to dictate, declared that the council could
not, consistently with its dignity, return to Trent, unless the prelates who,
by remaining there, had discovered a schismatic spirit, would first repair to
Bologna, and join their brethren; and that, even after their junction, the
council could not renew its consultations with any prospect of benefit to the
church, if the Germans did not prove their intention of obeying its future
decrees to be sincere, by yielding immediate obedience to those which it bad
already passed.
This
answer was communicated to the emperor by the pope, who at the same time
exhorted him to comply with demands which appeared to be so reasonable. But
Charles was better acquainted with the duplicity of the pope's character than
to be deceived by such a gross artifice, he knew that the prelates of Bologna
durst utter no sentiment but what Paul inspired; and, therefore, overlooking
them as mere tools in the band of another, be considered their reply as a full
discovery of the pope's intentions. As he could no longer hope to acquire such
an ascendant in the council as to render it subservient to his own plan, he saw
it to be necessary that Paul should not have it in his power to turn against
him the authority of so venerable an assembly.
In order to prevent this, he
sent two Spanish lawyers to Bologna [Jan. 16, 1548], who, in the presence of
the legates, protested. That the translation of the council to that place had
been unnecessary, and founded on false or frivolous pretexts; that while it
continued to meet there, it ought to be deemed an unlawful and schismatical
conventicle; that all its decisions ought of course to be held as null and
invalid; and that since the pope, together with the corrupt ecclesiastics who
depended on him, had abandoned the care of the church, the emperor, as its
protector, would employ all the power which God had committed to him, in order
to preserve it from those calamities with which it was threatened. A few days
after [Jan. 23], the Imperial ambassador at Rome demanded an audience of the
pope, and in presence of all the cardinals, as well as foreign ministers,
protested against the proceedings of the prelates at Bologna, in terms equally
harsh and disrespectful
It
was not long before Charles proceeded to carry these threats, which greatly
alarmed both the pope and council at Bologna, into execution. He let the diet
know the ill success of his endeavors to procure a favorable answer to their
petition, and that the pope, equally regardless of their entreaties, and of his
services to the church, had refused to gratify them by allowing the council to
meet again at Trent; that, though all hope of holding this assembly in a place,
where they might look for freedom of debate and judgment, was not to be given
up, the prospect of it was, at present, distant and uncertain; that in the mean
time, Germany was torn in pieces by religious dissensions, the purity of the
faith corrupted, and the minds of the people disquieted with a multiplicity of
new opinions and controversies formerly unknown among Christians; that, moved
by the duty which he owed to them as their sovereign, and to the church as its
protector, he had employed some divines of known abilities and learning, to
prepare a system of doctrine, to which all should conform, until a council,
such as they wished for, could be convocated. This system was compiled by
Pflug, Helding, and Agricola, of whom the two former were dignitaries in the
Romish church, but remarkable for their pacific and healing spirit; the last
was a protestant divine, suspected, not without reason, of having been gained
by bribes and promises, to betray or mislead his party on this occasion. The
articles presented to the diet of Ratisbon in the year one thousand five
hundred and forty-one, in order to reconcile the contending parties, served as
a model for the present work.
THE INTERIM OF THE EMPEROR